Is Wi-Fi More Secure Than Cellular?
Imagine you’re doing some online banking or sending sensitive business information to a colleague – would you feel more comfortable doing it over a Wi-Fi or cellular network?
As more and more of our activities move online, the question of network security is central to how we live and work. Both Wi-Fi and cellular networks are designed with security in mind, but each comes with its own set of strengths and weaknesses.
Which brings us to the topic of this blog post: is Wi-Fi more secure than cellular?
The short answer is that cellular data is more secure than public Wi-Fi. That’s because cellular networks are built on encryption and don’t rely on shared access points. That said, a well-configured private Wi-Fi network can be just as safe – sometimes even more reliable than cellular.
Of course, complexities apply, but if you’re still confused, then fear not. In this post, we’ll be taking a closer look at how Wi-Fi and cellular networks compare, what the risks are and how you can protect your data wherever you connect. Let’s dive in.
Jump to:
How Does Wi-Fi Security Work?
Wi-Fi is built on a set of protocols that work together to prevent attackers from intercepting data. However, the level of protection depends on the standard in use, the network configuration and the device running it. Most Wi-Fi networks depend on some form of the Wi-Fi Protected Access (WPA) protocol, of which there are two main versions in use.
WPA2
WPA2 is a security standard that protects data on Wi-Fi networks through advanced protocols. The standard uses algorithms to encrypt data that are strong enough to resist brute-force attacks. On top of this, WAP2 introduced measures to check that packets of data hadn’t been corrupted or altered in transit.
While WPA2 remains secure when implemented properly, its weakness lies in the fact that it relies on passwords. Attackers might be able to intercept the initial connection or “handshake” process between a device and router or attempt to crack the password with a dictionary attack. In summary, this means a WPA2 network is only as strong as the password protecting it.
WPA3
WPA3 improves on WPA2 by adding some extra security features with regard to passwords, using protocols that make it harder for attackers to guess weak passwords using dictionary attacks. It also enforces tougher encryption, matching the levels recommended by governments. The main drawback is that not all devices and routers support WAP3 yet, but it will eventually replace WPA2.
How Does Cellular Security Work?
Cellular networks rely on a global set of standards that include built-in encryption and authentication by default. SIM cards are at the heart of this technology. They hold a secret key that proves your identity to the network through a process called challenge-response authentication. Once authenticated, traffic is encrypted to protect against packet sniffers. The level of encryption varies according to the technology used, with 2G being weaker than 5G. If you’d like to learn more about how cellular security works, read our blog, Is Cellular Data Secure?
Owing to the above, cellular networks are considered to be more secure than public Wi-Fi networks, but they aren’t impenetrable. The main vulnerability comes from IMSI catchers (also known as “stingrays”), which can impersonate a cell tower and trick devices into connecting with it. Though 5G has introduced some protections against spoofing, older technologies are still vulnerable.
If your 5G signal drops, so does your security. Discover how an Ofcom-approved signal booster can keep attackers at bay.
Wi-Fi vs Cellular: Which Is More Secure?
Though cellular is generally seen to be more secure than Wi-Fi (especially public Wi-Fi), there are a few caveats to consider.
But firstly, the reason that cellular often comes out on top is that public Wi-Fi networks are often poorly secured, meaning that your traffic may not be encrypted end-to-end. This makes it a lot easier for attackers to intercept your data using simple tools. To come back to our original question, don’t do anything important on them!
But the picture changes over private Wi-Fi. A well-configured WPA3 network with a strong, unique password can be just as secure as cellular and, in many cases, is often more reliable. So long as your router is regularly updated and configured to block unauthorised access, that should be enough to keep attackers at bay.
Of course, as technology improves, so does security. With its stronger levels of encryption and authentication, as well as protection from IMSI catchers, 5G raises the bar over previous generations. This makes it significantly more resilient and the best option if you’re far away from a trusted private Wi-Fi network.
Staying Secure: Best Practices
Regardless of where you’re connecting, following a few best practices can help you keep your data secure from hackers. We’d always recommend the following precautions to reduce your risk:
Use a VPN
If you’re sending data over a public Wi-Fi network, then using a VPN adds an extra layer of security to your session. That’s because it works by creating a secure tunnel for your traffic, making sure that even if someone intercepts it, they won’t be able to read it.
Keep Software Updated
Regularly updating your router firmware (the software that controls its basic functions) and device operating system keeps you up to date with any patches that address emerging threats.
Disable Auto-Join for Open Networks
While we all have a rough idea of which networks we should trust, that’s not always the case for our devices. Many phones are set to automatically join the nearest available Wi-Fi network, which can leave you vulnerable to so-called “evil twin” attacks, where a public Wi-Fi host pretends to be a legitimate network.
Enable Two-Factor Authentication
Even if someone is able to intercept sensitive information, like your password, having 2FA enabled on your device adds an extra layer of protection to important accounts.
Enforce Security Policies
Most businesses have security policies, but how many of these are actually enforced? Maintaining an up-to-date infrastructure and making sure that all employees are following device management policies is one of the best ways to prevent a breach of your network.
Final Thoughts: Is Wi-Fi More Secure Than Cellular?
The short answer is that if you’re out in public, it’s probably safer to use cellular data – especially if it’s 5G. But at home or in the office, a well-secured private Wi-Fi can be just as safe. Of course, neither option is 100% risk-free. The safest choice depends on where you are and how the network is configured. Always take precautions when sending and receiving sensitive data – especially if you’re on an unfamiliar network.
Looking to keep your team connected securely? NetCov designs and installs Ofcom-approved signal-boosting solutions across the country. We work with companies from a wide range of sectors, installing high-quality signal boosters in London, Manchester, Birmingham, Bristol and other cities in the United Kingdom. Get in touch with our team today for a free quote.